How To Chose The Insulation That Is Going To Give You The Best Bang For Your Buck: Spray Foam Vs Fiberglass Insulation

Is your home or office starting to feel cold as the weather changes, even though you’ve turned your furnace on and turned up the thermostat? If so, you may have inadequate insulation.

Insulation helps maintain comfortable temperatures in your home or office building. If you don’t have sufficient insulation, you may be paying much more for your heating or cooling bill than you should have to.

Luckily, this situation can be remedied by installing new insulation. What type is best, though?

We have the know-how you need when it comes to spray foam insulation vs. fiberglass. Keep reading to learn about these two options.

Some Things to Keep in Mind

As you read about these two types of insulation, there are some things you should keep in mind. 

First, what is your budget? These options don’t cost the same, so it’s good to know what you can afford before you’re sold on one or the other.

What’s the scope of your project? If you’re doing an entire building or house, that’s going to affect your budget. If you’re doing something smaller you may be able to afford the more expensive option even on a small budget.

Keep these and any other needs in mind as you read about these two types of insulation.

Fiberglass Insulation

Fiberglass insulation comes in thick sheets or rolls of fibrous material called batts. It’s a common material in many older homes throughout the United States. One reason for this is the low upfront cost.

You may save on cost but you pay for it in effectiveness. Fiberglass insulation does help to filter cold and hot air out to some degree, but it has no true air seal. Air will still flow in and out of your house or business with this type of insulation.

Easy installation is another reason fiberglass is so popular. Homeowners can normally install this themselves. Though it’s smart to hire a professional to ensure proper installation, if necessary, you could do it yourself.

While this may sound like a major benefit, keep in mind that fiberglass batts can sag and deteriorate over time. This means you’re left with gaps that don’t provide any insulation at all.

How it Works

This type of insulation is made up of lots of tiny fibers of glass. This barrier of glass fibers stops some of the air that tries to flow through it, but it is nowhere near as effective as spray foam insulation.

Spray Foam Insulation

There are two types of spray foam insulation: closed-cell and open-cell. Both are effective.

Closed-cell spray foam completely blocks airflow from inside or outside of your home or office. This means you’ll have better control over the building’s internal temperature as well as your heating and cooling bills.

Closed-cell spray foam also adds structural strength to the building. This is ideal for areas with the potential for high winds or earthquakes. It’s also helpful when the home or building could use more support for upper levels.

Not only does spray foam block air, but it’s also resistant to moisture and mold.

Open-cell spray foam is usually a less expensive option than closed cell, and can not only be used as insulation but also to help with sound reduction.

How it Works

Spray foam is made of a polymer. When applied, it expands to fill in space.

Closed-cell foam hardens as it dries. This allows it to effectively block all air that tries to penetrate it.

Open-cell foam stays soft and it absorbs air that tries to pass through it. Now that you know a bit about each type of insulation, here’s how they stack up against each other.

The Cost

When paying for fiberglass insulation you’ll pay by the square foot. 

The cost of insulating a room or home with fiberglass will depend on how much space you want to cover and how much R-value you need to achieve.

Spray foam is paid for by board foot instead of by square foot. A board foot is a space that is one inch thick and one foot wide and long. For example, a 1,000 square feet area covered with 3” of closed-cell spray foam is equivalent to 3,000 board feet.

One board foot of closed-cell spray foam can cost you double to triple the price of a square foot of fiberglass insulation. But keep in mind that you get much better insulation and air sealing with spray foam.

Length of Life

Fiberglass insulation can last several years, but during that time it loses its effectiveness and you never have a complete seal against airflow. The level of effectiveness will depend on if any moisture is present, too. You may need to replace this type of insulation or add to it as it settles and deteriorates over time.

Spray foam, on the other hand, can last as long as 80 years or more. It’s a much more permanent and effective option. While you’ll pay more upfront, the longevity and efficiency of spray foam make it a very cost-effective option.

Sound and Allergy Considerations

If you’re looking for insulation that also blocks sound, fiberglass isn’t the best option. While it will block some sound, open-cell spray foam blocks a lot more of it.

Spray foam helps to block pollen and dust too, which is great for people with allergies.

Spray Foam Insulation vs. Fiberglass: Which is Best?

When it comes to which is best in the spray foam insulation vs. fiberglass debate, spray foam wins, hands down. This is due in part to its ability to stay in place once applied, this ultimately creates a constant air barrier. More importantly though due to this constant air barrier your HVAC system does not have to work anywhere near the capacity it is used to, this ultimately makes you comfortable year-round as well as reduces the strain on your wallet. As mentioned before yes spray foam insulation does have a higher upfront cost but saving a ton of money over the long term while being consistently comfortable is the ultimate goal. Give us a call at 1-845-361-1110, or visit us a to schedule your no-obligation consultation today!

our service area

We serve the following areas

  • Bushkill
  • Dingmans Ferry
  • Greeley
  • Greentown
  • Hawley
  • Lackawaxen
  • Matamoras
  • Milford
  • Millrift
  • Paupack
  • Rowland
  • Shohola
  • Tafton
  • Tamiment
New York
  • Barryville
  • Bellvale
  • Bethel
  • Cochecton
  • Cuddebackville
  • Eldred
  • Florida
  • Forestburgh
  • Glen Spey
  • Greenwood Lake
  • Highland Lake
  • Hillburn
  • Hortonville
  • Huguenot
  • Johnson
  • Kenoza Lake
  • Lake Huntington
  • Narrowsburg
  • New Hampton
  • New Milford
  • Otisville
  • Pine Island
  • Pond Eddy
  • Port Jervis
  • Slate Hill
  • Sloatsburg
  • Smallwood
  • Sparrow Bush
  • Sterling Forest
  • Tallman
  • Tuxedo Park
  • Unionville
  • Warwick
  • Westtown
  • White Lake
  • Yulan
Our Locations:

2901 Route 17K
Bullville, NY 10915